I got my New Cherry Pickers Guide - anyone else got it?

[WaterSport]

Opinions, thoughts????
WS

[kloccwork419]

I told myself I would never buy one again until it gets some good reviews. The last one was really bad. Between the prices and what was on there compared to what wasn't was real big with me..hopefully it's a good one because I liked the older one

[Roller]

[QUOTE=WaterSport;280251]Opinions, thoughts????


That was pretty quick from the heads up we got only a month ago. Need to get mine but in the meantime; did the 2011P-1DO-004 make it?

[mrmike916]

Was considering, but haven't yet. I did notice the updated CPG varietys at Varietyvista.com

http://www.varietyvista.com/CPG%20Varieties%20cents.htm

[duck620]

My book shipped yesterday(9-30)

[WaterSport]

No 2011. But the 2014 DDO did. Its actually a bit of a let down. Oldest coin addition...1934 D DDO. After that you jump to the 42 and 43 DDO, and then it seems its all memorials. That makes it affordable and possible of finding stuff. And yes, an even crappier picture of the 1911 D RPM 3!

Oh well, Just my opinion.

WS

[Roller]

No 2011. But the 2014 DDO did. Its actually a bit of a let down. Oldest coin addition...1934 D DDO. After that you jump to the 42 and 43 DDO, and then it seems its all memorials. That makes it affordable and possible of finding stuff. And yes, an even crappier picture of the 1911 D RPM 3!

Oh well, Just my opinion.

WS

I think the fix is in. I'll skip buying it. It's BS.

[kloccwork419]

Its good they added some memorials so PCGS will attribute them as such...bout it

[trails]

I wont buy one until they add at least one trail die into the mix. They are intentionally ignore a whole class of varieties.

BJ Neff

[centMD]

Was anything delisted?

Dan

[WaterSport]

7 Coins delisted:

FS-01-1951 D-521 Misplaced Mint mark (D in 9)
FS-01-1955 D-511 RPM (D over Horizontal D)
FS-01-1964-803 DDR
FS-01-1969 D-901 Missing Designers Initials
FS-01-1971-102 DDO
FS-01-1980 D-000 OMM
FS-01-2000 S-901 Circulation Rev

[Roller]

7 Coins delisted:

FS-01-1951 D-521 Misplaced Mint mark (D in 9)
FS-01-1955 D-511 RPM (D over Horizontal D)
FS-01-1964-803 DDR
FS-01-1969 D-901 Missing Designers Initials
FS-01-1971-102 DDO
FS-01-1980 D-000 OMM
FS-01-2000 S-901 Circulation Rev

Just one more question if you will. What value do they attach to the 2014 DDO?

[Brad]

So glad to see the 69D removed.

Do you have a list of the newest additions?

[jcuve]

...Do you have a list of the newest additions?

Working from Wiles page with the numbers I'll add what I see below. I have many of these unless noted...

2014 DDO-001 FS-101 (don't have)
2006 DDO-003 FS-102
1996 DDO-001 FS-101 (why no ddo-002 as well?)
1987D RPM-003 FS-501
1983D DDO-001 FS-101 (somehow I don't have this)
1983 DDR-002 FS-802
1966 DDR-001 FS-801 (don't have nor seen one in person)
1963 DDR-006 FS-801 Proof
1962 DDR-020 FS-801 Proof (I am not sure what this one even looks like)
1960D RPM-001 FS-502 (hard to believe this wasn't added ages ago...)
1960 DDR-009 FS-801 Proof (don't have this one)
1956D RPM-016 FS-502
1956 DDR-004 FS-801 proof
1956 DDO-002 FS-501 proof
1955 DDO-004/DDR-004 FS-103/801 proof
1953D RPM-028 FS-502
1949S DDO-001 FS-101 (weird being that DDO-002 and 003 are just as nice and look similar)
1946S IMM-001 FS-501 inverted S
1945 DDO-013 FS-101
1944D DDO-001 FS-101
1943 DDR-001 FS-801
1942 DDO-008 FS-104
1942 DDO-002 FS-101
1934D DDO-001 FS-101
1930D RPM-001 FS-501 (I don't have this rpm. A little surprised - is it really in the book? )

[Magers]

Odd that some of those were added and things like the 1912 s rpm were left out. I was really hoping that would get in.