The attribution Process

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mustbebob
    Lincoln Cent Variety Expert
    • Jul 2008
    • 12758

    #1

    The attribution Process

    First off, I apologize for the length of this post. I believe it needs to be be said though.

    This post is aimed at the individual who emailed me and complained that the $3 per coin attribution fee charged at coppercoins was ‘way too much’ and the work was hardly worth spending money on.
    First of all, your words and tone really made me angry. Your lack of knowledge on the attribution process is probably at fault, but your people skills really need a bit of work. For your benefit, and those who may not know what goes in to attributions, the following steps are used for attributing ONE coin. If you send a package, then multiply this by the number of coins you send. The following is used for coppercoins.com. Other attributers may do it differently.
    When a coin is received, a quick examination under the scope will first determine if the coin is a candidate for further inspection. Some times, we can immediately disregard a coin if it ends up being post mint damage, or any of the other anomalies not associated with varieties. Once that is determined, we try to determine the class of doubled die or RPM. This is done based on our experience. We really do try to make this process as easy and quick as possible. However, circulated coins may lead to a longer examination period.
    If the coin shows a relatively well known variety, we normally are able to attribute it to a number pretty easily. If it is not well known, this is where the research comes in. Many attributers own libraries of books to help identify a coin. Some of us use the internet or our own libraries for this purpose. Either way, our goal here is to see if it has been previously been reported, and assigned a number. This step may take a SIGNIFICANT amount of time. Some dates (1960D for instance) contain almost 200 known varieties. An RPM for this date will require quite a bit of time to narrow down. If we find a likely match, we must try to match markers to make absolutely sure.
    Let’s say that all of our research shows that this variety has not been reported before, and we wish to list it. Each coin is examined for markers used to help identify a particular coin. Photographs are taken of the anomaly, and markers. Those photos then need to be edited to fit the format of our filing system. Once the photos are edited, they are uploaded to the site, and then the die data needs to be added. This includes the die description, assignment of a number, research of pricing data, and identifying the marker info. Once this is all put together and loaded on to the site, I can say I am done. This was all for ONE coin.
    The normal time per coin can vary greatly, but normally, it can take ˝ hour to 45 minutes to perform all theses steps. Some coins take minutes; I have had others take more than an hour. So, if I can do 2 an hour, I just made $6. (I do believe that’s a bit below minimum wage). Keep in mind that I also do this in my spare time. I work a full day, then come home and work on coin attributions.
    You can ask any one of a number of people on this forum if they feel the $3 fee was worth it. You can also ask these same people how many times I have actually charged full price. When I schedule packages, the dialogue some times includes a deal of some sort. Other times it may be full price. Either way, you are free to select whoever you want to attribute your coins. Each and every club charges fees for this service. I will not knock any of those other clubs. As a matter of fact, I am a member of almost all of them. Coppercoins.com offers the ability to see a new addition to the files the fastest. When I complete the evaluation, the coins pics and data are available immediately.
    So basically, maybe you now have a better understanding of the process. If you feel the $3 per coin attribution fee is still overpriced, feel free not to deal with us any more. We made coppercoins.com so you would have the ability to attribute your own coins. You are more than welcome to go about it that way.

    To everyone else out there, I apologize for this long post. Some of the newer folks may now have an understanding of how the attribution process works.
    Bob Piazza
    Former Lincoln Cent Attributer Coppercoins.com
  • fugnchill

    #2
    I can't believe someone complained about the $3 fee. I feel guilty for only paying someone $5 for their attribution. Although I do realize what goes into the process and highly appreciate their work. It sounds as though someone thought they found something and it turned out they didn't. I hope this person has calmed down and understands what is involved and swallows their pride and apologizes to you.

    Thanks for the post Bob.
    Lestrrr

    Comment

    • RWBILLER
      Member
      • Jul 2008
      • 6870

      #3
      Bob:
      The only thing you can do - so not to get a resentment - is pray for the person.
      Roger
      Roger
      ""Time and Tide wait for no man"

      Comment

      • Brad
        Founder: Lincoln Cent Resource

        • Nov 2007
        • 4949

        #4
        I'm not sure who critizied the price, but I think that $3 per coin is more than fair and is the lowest price out there. It is not like they are making millions off their attributions. I'm sure Bob and Chuck have spent a lot more $ building Coppercoins.com then they have earned. I agree with Bob, if $3 is too much for you then find someone else or attribute them yourself.
        Brad
        Lincoln Cent Resource
        My PCGS Registry

        Comment

        • kloccwork419
          Banned
          • Sep 2008
          • 6800

          #5
          I would just say the name. Put him/her on front street and be taught a lesson.

          Thats just me.

          Nice post Bob.

          Comment

          • mustbebob
            Lincoln Cent Variety Expert
            • Jul 2008
            • 12758

            #6
            Thanks guys. I didn't post the person's name because I didn't need to embarrass them or myself. I have been known to get a little too sensitive about these things, and have said the wrong thing to the wrong people.
            If he chooses to identify himself, then that is fine. I will debate him privately, or in the public forum. The biggest reason I was so P-O'd was that the person never sent anything to be attributed. He was complaining about the pricing before he ever did anything.
            Anyway, we will see where this goes. It would be just as good if he doesn't say anything else. He received a slightly different personalized copy of this before I posted it here, and I have received no response.
            Bob Piazza
            Former Lincoln Cent Attributer Coppercoins.com

            Comment

            • JeanK
              Member
              • Sep 2008
              • 5696

              #7
              I was going to post a reply to this, but the person who complained has got my dander up and I can be ornery when that happens so I won't cause any trouble, this time.
              Jean

              Comment

              • Steven
                Member
                • Dec 2007
                • 2691

                #8
                I think the $3. is more than a reasonable price for an attribution and the lowest I have seen unless you would want to count those Bob has attributed without a fee. He has even given away doubles on some coins he owns as well as passing on vast amounts of knowledge he has aquired about the subject of coins at NO FEE.
                I would suppose that if someone didn't want to pay an attribution fee, no matter how little, they could gain the knowledge about the subject and do it themselves.
                I got a feeling that it would be a lot more expensive that way. Such as a fees for a library of books, training, some more books and more training, photography equipment, comunications with many other attributors and collectors, travel, and a lot of time and money for a set up to get started.

                Myself I'm glad Bob is down there in Niceville helping us out.

                This post is starting to sound like I appreciate Bob or something so I'll quit now.

                Comment

                • tmawhit
                  Member
                  • Jul 2008
                  • 194

                  #9
                  Long or not, I always appreciate reading your (Bob's) postings. There is always something worthwhile to read when you respond to someone's inquiry.

                  Knock'em out.

                  Tom W.

                  Comment

                  • jcuve
                    Moderator, Die & Variety Expert
                    • Apr 2008
                    • 15458

                    #10
                    $3...(heck even $5) is more than reasonable and I am sure that most LCR members would agree on that. Sorry to hear that (someone out there) feels different. I know I appreciate all that you do Bob - on Coppercoins.com, your attributions and also the time you take to contribute to the forums!



                    Jason Cuvelier


                    MadDieClashes.com - ErrorVariety.com
                    TrailDies.com - Error-ref.com - Port.Cuvelier.org
                    CONECA

                    (images © Jason Cuvelier 2008-18)___________________

                    Comment

                    • corroded
                      Member
                      • Mar 2009
                      • 591

                      #11
                      Bob, you have done many coins for me, nearly 60 and I know you work yourself into a sweat doing it, especially with all the fun you had with that 1992D DDR that time. You are worth the three dollars and more. Shame on that person!

                      Bill

                      Comment

                      • AgCollector

                        #12
                        I could see someone comparing the probable value of many varieties ($3-$5 or less, especially if circulated) and thinking that it's not worth it to pay that much, just to get it attributed. Kind of like paying $20 to get a coin slabbed when the value is only $5 or $10.

                        It probably has more to do with, as you mention Bob, bad people skills. It's not like the fee is hidden at all, and people should not expect that you work for free. It's easy to complain without thinking through all the effort that goes into attributions.

                        Heck, I'm willing to bet that the person never even bothered to look into alternate attributors and their prices because anyone who takes the time to "do their homework" would be thoughtful enough not to make the kind of comment that was made.

                        Comment

                        • koinmon
                          Member
                          • Oct 2008
                          • 2207

                          #13
                          Long or not well said bob!!!

                          Comment

                          • Daggit

                            #14
                            Well....heck, I will do what Jean did....

                            Comment

                            • brefos77

                              #15
                              i agree with everyone else. $3 is worth assuring you have a coin that may be worth hundreds, instead of being cheap and chunking it.

                              Comment

                              Working...