1911 "too small" - variety? error? nuthin'?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Circa
    Member
    • Nov 2008
    • 34

    #16
    Mike Diamond has spoken:

    Your coin was immersed in acid or other corrosive liquid for an extended period. The perfect centering, abnormally thin design rim, abnormally thin letters, and uniformly blurred design are characteristic of such mischief.
    So sayeth the master.

    Comment

    • CCC

      #17
      Mike is the man. Keep searching Circa.

      Comment

      • snowman
        Member
        • Dec 2007
        • 494

        #18
        thats hard to beleive that over 42% of the coin was eaten away with acid/chemicals and still retain an over all even characteristics in the penny pictures

        i would think the coins pattern would be uneven or at least the letters would be totally gone

        Snowman

        Comment

        • Circa
          Member
          • Nov 2008
          • 34

          #19
          Well I sorta thought that too, especially after looking at pictures of "acid bathed" coins VS. "foreign planchet" versions. But what do I know?


          Originally posted by snowman
          thats hard to beleive that over 42% of the coin was eaten away with acid/chemicals and still retain an over all even characteristics in the penny pictures

          i would think the coins pattern would be uneven or at least the letters would be totally gone

          Snowman

          Comment

          • Brad
            Founder: Lincoln Cent Resource

            • Nov 2007
            • 4949

            #20
            I still would not throw it away....
            Brad
            Lincoln Cent Resource
            My PCGS Registry

            Comment

            • 1sgret

              #21
              Sorry to hear that. However he is the professional and it would make a great example piece in your collection for man made errors.

              Comment

              • Circa
                Member
                • Nov 2008
                • 34

                #22
                No, not gonna chuck it out the window just yet. I've hit the "it can't be THAT because you're not one of us" wall too many times to crawl away from the first paternal look-down-the-nose I encounter. Besides, the examples of acid-bathed coins I've seen online all look like sand castles just after high tide, whereas this thing is clean, smooth and uniform with a sharp rim. Doesn't fit.

                Comment

                • 1sgret

                  #23
                  Things to consider: What kind of acid bath, How strong, How Long or was it vinegar and salt with a wall converter clamped onto the coin to clean it from being in the ground. You can always send it to a grading company for their analysis. Just a thought to help you out.

                  Comment

                  • kloccwork419
                    Banned
                    • Sep 2008
                    • 6800

                    #24
                    Whats you best assumption for getting crud off a lincoln Joe???

                    Or anyone who has a great idea?

                    Comment

                    • 1sgret

                      #25
                      [quote=kloccwork419;12040]Whats you best assumption for getting crud off a lincoln Joe???

                      What kind of crud? PVC, Corrosion or ------

                      Comment

                      • kloccwork419
                        Banned
                        • Sep 2008
                        • 6800

                        #26
                        DIRT. Build-up of uh.....lol...Crud...lolol. In the tiny area of Letters and Date

                        Comment

                        • 1sgret

                          #27
                          I believe we had a discussion on this using "GOO Gone" and a thorn from a rose bush. Anyway that's what I use thanks to Bob and a few others.

                          Sometimes I soak the coin in rubbing alcohol and then rinse it in warm water. Do not rub the coin.

                          Comment

                          • CCC

                            #28
                            If I have over 50 I usually just boil them. Work's fine if you have ceramic coated collender and put baking soda in the boiling water after about 15-20 minutes. The baking soda will bring the crud to the top.

                            Comment

                            • 1sgret

                              #29
                              Never even crossed my mind even when I used to Metal Detect. Good Idea David!

                              Comment

                              • kloccwork419
                                Banned
                                • Sep 2008
                                • 6800

                                #30
                                huh?...ill have to try that. It doesnt do anything to the finish does it?. I know home remedy is to use ketchup on copper pans but I used it on a coin and it take the natural color right out.

                                Comment

                                Working...