I got my New Cherry Pickers Guide - anyone else got it?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mikelellis

    #31
    Originally posted by onecent1909
    Question? Are they delisted or do they just not have the pictures and a place in the book?
    I do not have a new copy yet... however in the back of my old copy is a list of all FS numbers new listing and old listing... with the new ( at that time ) listing numbers and the old listing numbers
    I know that the 1958 type 2 half dollar has a cherrypickers FS number and is listed in the back of the book... but it does not have pics and a placement in the 2nd cheryypickers that covers everything above the nickle
    Are you sure this is a 1958 and not a 1956? I am not aware of the 1958 and we are working on Volume II now so I would like to hear more about this coin. Thanks!

    Comment

    • mikelellis

      #32
      Originally posted by Roller
      I think the fix is in. I'll skip buying it. It's BS.
      The fix? What is the fix? I am guessing that is an insinuation of some kind but that is not the case if that is what you mean. Don't know what you mean by BS either. Thank you for your opinion though.

      Comment

      • mikelellis

        #33
        Originally posted by jcuve
        Working from Wiles page with the numbers I'll add what I see below. I have many of these unless noted...

        2014 DDO-001 FS-101 (don't have)
        2006 DDO-003 FS-102
        1996 DDO-001 FS-101 (why no ddo-002 as well?)
        1987D RPM-003 FS-501
        1983D DDO-001 FS-101 (somehow I don't have this)
        1983 DDR-002 FS-802
        1966 DDR-001 FS-801 (don't have nor seen one in person)
        1963 DDR-006 FS-801 Proof
        1962 DDR-020 FS-801 Proof (I am not sure what this one even looks like)
        1960D RPM-001 FS-502 (hard to believe this wasn't added ages ago...)
        1960 DDR-009 FS-801 Proof (don't have this one)
        1956D RPM-016 FS-502
        1956 DDR-004 FS-801 proof
        1956 DDO-002 FS-501 proof
        1955 DDO-004/DDR-004 FS-103/801 proof
        1953D RPM-028 FS-502
        1949S DDO-001 FS-101 (weird being that DDO-002 and 003 are just as nice and look similar)
        1946S IMM-001 FS-501 inverted S
        1945 DDO-013 FS-101
        1944D DDO-001 FS-101
        1943 DDR-001 FS-801
        1942 DDO-008 FS-104
        1942 DDO-002 FS-101
        1934D DDO-001 FS-101
        1930D RPM-001 FS-501 (I don't have this rpm. A little surprised - is it really in the book? )
        The 1930-D really is in the book. It was in the last one too. Just no picture! Because there was no picture we kept it in the book and gave it a picture.

        Comment

        • onecent1909
          Wrong Design Die Expert
          • Feb 2012
          • 2597

          #34
          Originally posted by mikelellis
          Are you sure this is a 1958 and not a 1956? I am not aware of the 1958 and we are working on Volume II now so I would like to hear more about this coin. Thanks!
          Mr. Ellis.. not wanting to high jack this thread
          You can check out my Wrong Design Die Exhibit sticky by going to forum then Off topic then Sticky
          or use this link

          I have sense done more research on this half variety and others.
          not much value difference in the type 1 or the type 2 for 1958 or the 1959
          Last edited by onecent1909; 10-04-2015, 08:10 PM.
          Member: Florida State representative for the ANA, Florida state representative for CONECA, F.U.N. and the Ocala Coin Club

          Comment

          • onecent1909
            Wrong Design Die Expert
            • Feb 2012
            • 2597

            #35
            And Thank You Mike for chiming in and helping explaining some things with this book
            Member: Florida State representative for the ANA, Florida state representative for CONECA, F.U.N. and the Ocala Coin Club

            Comment

            • jfines69
              Member
              • Jun 2010
              • 28848

              #36
              I think Mr. Ellis should get a medal for coming over and taking a beating from the folks here... I have picked up a lot of excellent info from this thread... Thanks to everyone here and our visitor!!!
              Jim
              (A.K.A. Elmer Fudd) Be verwy verwy quiet... I'm hunting coins!!! Good Hunting!!!

              Comment

              • duck620
                Paid Member

                • Apr 2009
                • 2916

                #37
                Originally posted by Roller
                Just one more question if you will. What value do they attach to the 2014 DDO?
                2014-AU/15.00,MS-60/30.00,MS-63/50.00,MS-65/75.00.
                "2012 Finds HERE"

                Comment

                • duck620
                  Paid Member

                  • Apr 2009
                  • 2916

                  #38
                  Originally posted by trails
                  I wont buy one until they add at least one trail die into the mix. They are intentionally ignore a whole class of varieties.

                  BJ Neff
                  BJ,NO TRAIL DIE OR 2011-DDO.WHAT'S UP WITH THIS?.............BUT THEY DID LIST INDIAN HEAD 1864-1401(LATHE LINES).WHY NOT MODERN COINS?
                  KEN.
                  "2012 Finds HERE"

                  Comment

                  Working...