Canadian Bank Penny Box Find

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • 2centsworth
    • May 2025

    #1

    Canadian Bank Penny Box Find

    I've been perusing the Lincoln Cent Resource for the last year and been waiting for the chance to get my feet wet in the Lincoln Cent world over something simple. But it looks like I have to skip 'simple' for the sake of relating my box find of this past week!

    (As a preface, sorry, but this can't help but be a LONG post...!)

    I've been buying boxes of pennies on a fairly regular basis for almost 3 years now. During that time, I estimate I've searched 500,000 pennies - mostly Canadian.

    Two weeks ago I went to my bank to get 7 rolls of quarters (not for silver, just trying to complete a master Canadian set of nickel/steel quarters). While there, I decided at the last minute to get 2 boxes of pennies.

    On Friday, I finally had the time to search the boxes. The first box was typical for what I get in a CAN $25 box: about 25-30% copper, about 250 US cents (total of copper and zinc) and 3 King George VI and 2 or 3 wheaties. Plus a few choice UNC's and a large selection of 60's dates for my roll hoarding. These are very typical results for the bank boxes I get.

    Then, on to the second box. I opened the first roll and out popped a bunch of gray dried paint flecks, and about 10 King George and 15 wheaties! Ok... so I'm already ahead of the usual box results after only one roll! Then I noticed that the remaining 25 coins were all copper. I popped the second roll. Same results (including the paint flecks!). The pattern continued for all 50 rolls.

    Along the way, I started noticing that many of the wheats were older than the 1930's thru 50's that I normally get. The first one to stand out was a 1926D. Then a couple of 1919's. Then a new record - for me - a 1911! Then a 1913 and a 1912 within seconds of each other. Then, I just about fell off the couch... (see picture #2. The coins are in roughly the order I remember finding them.)

    When the shock wore off (about 2 days later!), I figured out the final totals:
    (out of the 2500 pennies) as follows:
    1) Copper - 2,494! (mostly US 1960's and nothing past 1978. The other six were late 2000's Canadian!)
    2) Wheats - 696!!! Yikes! More than 1 in every 4 was a wheat penny.
    3) King George VI - 231 pennies! (Every year from 1937 to 1952. 9 or 10 are in AU55 - AU58 condition.)
    4) King George V - One!
    5) Zero IHC!

    I'll skip all the rest of the juicy details for now, and let a few photos tell the story. Then I'll post again with a written listing of the top finds. There are 2 or 3 that REALLY stand out!

    The most amazing part looking back is I can't believe what ALMOST made it back into circulation if I hadn't grabbed those two boxes (i wasn't originally going to bother with pennies that day.)
    Attached Files
  • 2centsworth

    #2
    Canadian Box Find - Follow up

    Here's a written summation of the box breakdown as discussed above:

    1) Coppers - 2,496
    2) Wheats - 696
    3) George VI - 230
    4) George V - 1
    5) Oldest - 1909VDB
    6) Most valuable (US) - 1914D
    7) Most valuable (CAN) - 1949 'A' Points to Denticle in AU55

    Lincoln List Highlights:
    1909VDB, 1911, 1912, 1913 (x2), 1914, 1914D, 1916 (x2), 1917, 1918 (x5), 1918D, 1918S, 1919 (x4), 1920, 1920S, 1923, 1924 (x3), 1925 (x4), 1926 (x3), 1926D, 1927 (x5), 1927D, 1928, 1929 (x4), 1930 (x3), 1934 (x5), 1934D, 1935 (x7), 1936 (x11), 1936D, 1937 (x21), 1938, 1938D, 1939 (x8), 1939S, 1940 (x15), 1940D (x3). All the rest up to 1958 except missing the steelies and 52S and 55S.

    George VI Highlights:
    1937, 1938, 1939 (x4), 1940 (x21), 1941 (x15), 1942 (x20), 1943 (x18), 1944 (x13), 1945 (x23), 1946 (x16), 1947 (x11), 1947ml (x14), 1948 (x4), 1949 (x13), 1950 (x29), 1951 (x12), 1952 (x15), many more from 1953 to 1962.

    To document the Lincoln find, I started on a couple of cheapie Whitman albums for the different dates in circulation. The 1914D has gone straight into my (main) Dansco album and will stay there. This coin will never (willingly!) be sold by me!
    Attached Files

    Comment

    • tinytinkerbell
      Member
      • May 2011
      • 762

      #3
      OOOMMMMGGG!!!! nice haul!!!
      "Seek and you shall find" ...

      Comment

      • liveandievarieties
        TPG & Market Expert
        • Feb 2011
        • 6049

        #4
        Wow, I just picked up $25 in rolls this afternoon, now I gotta go.......

        Awesome finds, a 14D? You can search for the next hundred years and probably not expect to beat that wheat circ find. Way cool, thanks for sharing!
        [B][FONT=Franklin Gothic Medium][SIZE=2]Chris & Charity Welch- [COLOR=red]LIVEAN[/COLOR][COLOR=black]DIE[/COLOR][COLOR=blue]VARIETIES[/COLOR][/SIZE][/FONT][/B]
        [FONT=Franklin Gothic Medium]Purveyors of Modern Treasure [/FONT]

        Comment

        • 2centsworth

          #5
          Originally posted by liveandievarieties
          Wow, I just picked up $25 in rolls this afternoon, now I gotta go.......

          Awesome finds, a 14D? You can search for the next hundred years and probably not expect to beat that wheat circ find. Way cool, thanks for sharing!
          I don't even understand it, truthfully. I figured out the odds of finding one at about 6 billion to one. WAAY better chance of winning the lottery.

          I've had ZERO expectation of ever even THINKING about finding one. Especially in collectible condition!

          Comment

          • dvn

            #6
            WOW!!! Simply AMAZING!!! Congrats on your most excellent haul! Thanks for sharing and I enjoyed reading the story that comes with it.

            Billy

            Comment

            • 2centsworth

              #7
              Here's the Canadian Parts to the 'Haul'

              I held back on the Canadian George VI stuff as this is a LC forum. But for those who are interested, these also came from that killer box...

              Of particular note, I've never seen a better '1949 A to denticle'. It's kinda the Canadian equivalent of the 1955 DD in AU condition.
              Attached Files

              Comment

              • Roller
                Member
                • Feb 2010
                • 6973

                #8
                Geat fins 2Cents. I'm interested in how you search on the "couch" of which you "almost fell off".

                Comment

                • twoyankees
                  Member
                  • Oct 2010
                  • 913

                  #9
                  Originally posted by 2centsworth
                  I held back on the Canadian George VI stuff as this is a LC forum. But for those who are interested, these also came from that killer box...

                  Of particular note, I've never seen a better '1949 A to denticle'. It's kinda the Canadian equivalent of the 1955 DD in AU condition.
                  A great big WOW, great stuff and great story, I love it. The 1932 in the first pic is awesome, would love find something like that...someday. I've got a couple of Georges, i'll check them out, if I have any ?'s can I ask you? Tom

                  Comment

                  • hasfam
                    Paid Member

                    • May 2009
                    • 6291

                    #10
                    Great story and post. Amazing box finds. Super Congrats. I'm Very happy for you.
                    Rock
                    My LCR Photo Album of Graded Lincoln Cent Cherry Picker Varieties

                    Comment

                    • mustbebob
                      Lincoln Cent Variety Expert
                      • Jul 2008
                      • 12757

                      #11
                      Absolutely awesome. Congrats on a great score. Chances are, you will never have another box like that one, but we can always hope.
                      Bob Piazza
                      Former Lincoln Cent Attributer Coppercoins.com

                      Comment

                      • 2centsworth

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Roller
                        Geat fins 2Cents. I'm interested in how you search on the "couch" of which you "almost fell off".
                        Actually, I sit on the floor and use the couch as a table (it is a stiff modern Ikea couch, not a big fluffy thing). Then just to change things up I sit on the couch and use a high table for sub-sorting. (I have 5 piles going at a time - US zinc, CAN steel, CAN copper, US copper and a 'special' pile).

                        But in this case, my 'special' pile (wheats and KG) quickly became the biggest one and forced a little more gyrating!

                        Comment

                        • 2centsworth

                          #13
                          Originally posted by mustbebob
                          Absolutely awesome. Congrats on a great score. Chances are, you will never have another box like that one, but we can always hope.
                          2 years ago I bought 20 rolls from a very small town where my parents live and got about 250 wheats and 300 KG VI. Nothing of note, however. I thought THAT was my score of a lifetime. And learned to always buy boxes instead of the $10 worth I used to.

                          If something like a 1914D happens again (I DO need the S VDB!), I will start searching rolls full time for a living!

                          Comment

                          • 2centsworth

                            #14
                            Originally posted by twoyankees
                            A great big WOW, great stuff and great story, I love it. The 1932 in the first pic is awesome, would love find something like that...someday. I've got a couple of Georges, i'll check them out, if I have any ?'s can I ask you? Tom
                            Certainly. There are some interesting ones to look for: the 2 versions of the 1947ml (pointed and blunt), the 3 versions of the 1948, and the two 1949's. There are also some interesting 1962's, and 1965's.

                            But I LOVE the diversity of the Lincolns. I even keep zincs in good condition and will probably dig them out 20 years from now and search for varieties again...

                            Comment

                            • Cdiddle
                              Member
                              • Jul 2010
                              • 974

                              #15
                              Congrats on such a dream come true and thank you for sharing.
                              Cindy

                              Comment

                              Working...